This week’s Torah portion, Parshat Be’ha’a’lot’cha, from the Book of Numbers, mentions once again the concept of the anan, the Divine Cloud that covered the ancient Tent of Meeting at all times. And as Num. 9:17 indicates: “Whenever the cloud lifted from the Tent, the Israelites would set out accordingly; and at the spot where the cloud settled, there the Israelites would make camp.” The anan was their GPS. It told them when/where to go as they journeyed forth into the wilderness.
In his commentary on the passage, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch notes that “The cloud was the shepherd’s staff, by means of which God, Ro’eh Yisrael, the Shepherd of Israel, revealed to His flock where and when to camp and in which direction they were to journey forth. And we are told here that the will and intention of this guidance was unpredictable.”
Hirsch goes on to write that: “This is the teaching of the journey through the wilderness, from which we learned for all time to follow God’s guidance with devotion and trust, no matter how incomprehensible it may seem to us.”
That way of thinking: of an unquestioning trust and deference to God no matter what….served our people well for most of the last 2,000 years. And it seems to have resonated with Hirsch, a founder of Modern Orthodoxy in 19th century Germany.
But I would respectfully suggest to you today that that is a harder pill for us to swallow in the 21st century. Where was God during the Holocaust? And more aptly this week, we cannot help but ask: where was God in Oklahoma?
Pat Robertson answered that question this week. He said that e saiHHeeehhhhhhwhile God did not explicitly create the tornado, God absolutely had the ability to stop it. And God would have, if enough people had prayed for God to stop it. But because enough people didn’t pray, the tornado came.
And Fred Phelps Jr, associated with Westboro Baptist Church – an institution so filled with hate that I cannot believe I am mentioning them in these remarks – tweeted his answer as to where God was in Oklahoma. He wrote that the tornado occurred in Oklahoma as a punishment aimed at Oklahoma City Thunder basketball player Kevin Durant, who has been vocal in his public support for Washington Wizards’ player Jason Collins, who recently came out as the first openly gay male athlete in professional team sports.
So, according to Pat Robertson, the approximately 24 people who died in Oklahoma this week died because enough people didn’t pray, or that they didn’t pray hard enough. And Fred Phelps Jr notes that the tornado was a punishment against Kevin Durant and every other American who supports the rights of those who are gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender.
This tragedy can teach us something vitally important: that perhaps the time has passed for us to ascribe a literal belief in a God that has Will….in a deity that can decide to do something and then have the ability to actually intervene in the world and do it.
Martin Buber, reflecting on his own wrestling with God, concluded that: “The mystery [of God] is no longer disclosed – it has escaped.” In other words: we no longer live in a time and place where we have any ability whatsoever to speculate on how or why God would or would not have been able to do something in the world.
Buber goes on to write that all we can be sure of is “each mortal hour’s fullness of claim and responsibility. Though far from being equal to it, yet I know that in the claim I am claimed and may respond in responsibility, and know who speaks, and who demands a response.”
All we can do, every single day of our lives, is wake up and reaffirm that we human beings are responsible for one another in this world. All we can know with assurance is that there are people in the world who need us. And the only thing worth speculating on is whether or not we are prepared to answer those needs.
The first responders in Oklahoma have done that already. Family members and neighbors on the ground are, too.
What about us? What will our response to this modern day cloud be? Will we revert to ancient tropes of blind trust or hurtful, irrational justifications? Or will we respond to the needs of others, by giving tzedakah, sharing supplies, or donating blood?
May the ones who were injured be healed speedily. And may the memories of the innocents who died live on to be for a blessing, and let us say Amein.
Once again, I want to take this opportunity to sincerely thank the many friends who came out on Sunday morning to hear my lecture addressing both the pro and con [officiation] sides of the question regarding the role that of those who are not Jewish in Jewish ritual. Thank you for your patience as I continue on this "rabbinic quest" to discern whether my position and authority as Rabbi permits me to officiate at interfaith wedding ceremonies.
For those who were not able to be with us, the full text of my remarks from Sunday's Session 3 can be found here. The text reference sheet for Session 3 can be found here. Material from Session 1 in January can be found here. And material from Session 2 in February can be found here.
Your questions, thoughts, and reflections are most welcome....feel free to add a comment here on the blog, drop me an email, or call the temple office so that we can schedule a meeting together.
Kindly, Rabbi Brown
The welcome that I’ve received from the people of Israel. (Cheers, applause.) Thank you. I bring with me the support of the American people -- (cheers, applause) -- and the friendship that binds us together. (Cheers, applause.)
You know, over the last two days I’ve reaffirmed the bonds between our countries with Prime Minister Netanyahu and President Peres. I’ve borne witness to the ancient history of the Jewish people at the Shrine of the Book, and I’ve seen Israel’s shining future in your scientists and your entrepreneurs. This is a nation of museums and patents, timeless holy sites, groundbreaking innovation. Only in Israel could you see the Dead Sea Scrolls and the place where the technology onboard the Mars rover originated at the same time. (Cheers, applause.)
But what I’ve most looked forward to is the ability to speak directly to you, the Israeli people, especially so many young people who are here today -- (cheers, applause) -- to talk to you about the history that brought us here today and the future that you will make in the years to come.
Now, I know that in Israel’s vibrant democracy, every word, every gesture is carefully scrutinized. (Laughter.) But I -- I want to clear something up, just so you know: Any drama between me and my friend Bibi over the years was just a plot to create material for Eretz Nehederet. (Cheers, applause.) That’s the only -- only thing that was going on. We just -- we just wanted to make sure the writers had good material. (Laughter.)
I also know that I come to Israel on the eve of a sacred holiday -- the celebration of Passover. And that is where I would like to begin today. Just a few days from now Jews here in Israel and around the world will sit with family and friends at the Seder table and celebrate with songs, wine and symbolic foods. After enjoying Seders with family and friends in Chicago and on the campaign trail, I’m proud that I’ve now brought this tradition into the White House.
And I did so -- (applause) -- I did so because I wanted my daughters to experience the Haggadah and the story at the center of Passover that makes this time of year so powerful. It’s a story of centuries of slavery and years of wandering in the desert; a story of perseverance amidst persecution and faith in God and the Torah.
It’s a story about finding freedom in your own land. And for the Jewish people, this story is central to who you’ve become.
But it’s also a story that holds within it the universal human experience, with all of its suffering but also all of its salvation. It’s a part of the three great religions -- Judaism, Christianity and Islam -- that trace their origins to Abraham and see Jerusalem as sacred. And it’s a story that’s inspired communities across the globe, including me and my fellow Americans.
In the United States, a nation made of up people who crossed oceans to start anew, we’re naturally drawn to the idea of finding freedom in our land. To African-Americans, the story of the exodus was perhaps the central story, the most powerful image, about emerging from the grip of bondage to reach for liberty and human dignity -- a tale that was carried from slavery through the civil rights movement into today.
For generations, this promise helped people weather poverty and persecution while holding on to the hope that a better day was on the horizon. For me personally, growing up in far-flung parts of the world and without firm roots, the story spoke to a yearning within every human being for a home. (Applause.)
Of course, even as we draw strength from the story of God’s will and his gift of freedom expressed on Passover, we also know that here on Earth we must bear our responsibilities in an imperfect world.
That means accepting our measure of sacrifice and struggle, just like previous generations. It means us working through generation after generation on behalf of that ideal of freedom. As Dr. Martin Luther King said on the day before he was killed, “I may not get there with you. But I want you to know that we, as a people, will get to the promised land.” So just -- (applause) -- so just as Joshua carried on after Moses, the work goes on for all of you, the Joshua generation -- for justice and dignity, for opportunity and freedom.
For the Jewish people, the journey to the promise of the state of Israel wound through countless generations. It involved centuries of suffering and exile, prejudice and pogroms and even genocide. Through it all, the Jewish people sustained their unique identity and traditions, as well as a longing to return home. And while Jews achieved extraordinary success in many parts of the world, the dream of true freedom finally found its full expression in the Zionist idea -- to be a free people in your homeland.
And that’s why I believe that Israel is rooted not just in history and tradition but also in a simple and profound idea: the -- the idea that people deserve to be free in a land of their own. (Cheers, applause.)
Over the last 65 years, when Israel has been at its best, Israelis have demonstrated that responsibility does not end when you reach the promised land, it only begins.
And so Israel has been a refuge for the diaspora, welcoming Jews from Europe, from the former Soviet Union, from Ethiopia, from North Africa. (Applause.)
Israel has built a prosperous nation, through kibbutzeem that made the desert bloom, business that broadened the middle class, innovators who reached new frontiers, from the smallest microchip to the orbits of space.
Israel has established a thriving democracy with a spirited civil society and proud political parties and a tireless free press and a lively public debate -- lively may be an understatement. (Applause.)
And Israel has achieved all this even as it’s overcome relentless threats to its security, through the courage of the Israel Defense Forces and a citizenry that is so resilient in the face of terror.
This is the story of Israel. This is the work that has brought the dreams of so many generations to life. And every step of the way, Israel has built unbreakable bonds of friendship with my country, the United States of America. (Applause.)
Those ties began only eleven minutes after Israeli independence, when the United States was the first nation to recognize the State of Israel. (Applause.)
As President Truman said in explaining his decision to recognize Israel, he said, “I believe it has a glorious future before it, not just as another sovereign nation, but as an embodiment of the great ideals of our civilization.”
And since then, we’ve built a friendship that advances our shared interests. Together, we share a commitment to security for our citizens and the stability of the Middle East and North Africa. Together, we share a focus on advancing economic growth around the globe and strengthening the middle class within our own countries. Together, we share a stake in the success of democracy.
But the source of our friendship extends beyond mere interests, just as it has transcended political parties and individual leaders. America’s a nation of immigrants. America’s strengthened by diversity. America’s enriched by faith. We are governed not simply by men and women but by laws. We’re fueled by entrepreneurship and innovation, and we are defined by a democratic discourse that allows each generation to reimagine and renew our union once more. So in Israel, we see values that we share, even as we recognize what makes us different. That is an essential part of our bond.
Now, I stand here today mindful that for both our nations, these are some complicated times. We have difficult issues to work through within our own countries, and we face dangers and upheaval around the world. And when I look at young people within the United States, I think about the choices that they must make in their lives to define who we’ll be as a nation in this 21st century, particularly as we emerge from two wars and the worst recession since the Great Depression.
But part of the reason I like talking to young people is because no matter how great the challenges are, their idealism, their energy, their ambition always gives me hope. (Cheers, applause.)
And I see the same spirit in the young people here today. (Cheers, applause.) I believe that you will shape our future. And given the ties between our countries, I believe your future is bound to ours.
AUDIENCE MEMBER: (Inaudible.) (Mixed cheers and boos.)
PRESIDENT OBAMA: No, no. (Chuckles.)
AUDIENCE MEMBER: (Inaudible.)
PRESIDENT OBAMA: This is part of the lively debate that we talked about. (Cheers, applause.) This is good. (Cheers, applause.) (Chuckles.) The -- you know -- (cheers, applause) -- (chuckles) -- (continued cheers and applause) -- you know, I’d -- (chuckles) -- I have to say we actually arranged for that because it made me feel at home. (Laughter, cheers, applause.) You know, I -- I wouldn’t feel comfortable if I didn’t have at least one heckler. (Laughter.) (Chuckles.)
I’d like to focus on how we -- and when I say we, in particular young people -- can work together to make progress in three areas that will define our times: security, peace, and prosperity. (Applause.)
Let me begin with security. I’m proud that the security relationship between the United States and Israel has never been stronger. (Cheers, applause.) Never. More exercises between our militaries. More exchanges among our political and military and intelligence officials than ever before. The largest program to date to help you retain your qualitative military edge. These are the facts; these aren’t my opinions. These are facts.
But to me, this is not simply measured on a balance sheet. I know that here, in Israel, security is something personal. Here’s what I think about when I consider these issues.
When I consider Israel’s security, I think about children like Osher Twito, who I met in Sderot. (Applause.) Children, the same age as my own daughters, who went to bed at night fearful that a rocket would land in their bedroom simply because of who they are and where they live. (Applause.)
That reality is why we’ve invested in the Iron Dome system, to save countless lives, because those children deserve to sleep better at night. (Cheers, applause.)
That’s why we’ve made it clear time and again that Israel cannot accept rocket attacks from Gaza, and we have stood up for Israel’s right to defend itself. (Cheers, applause.) And that’s why Israel has a right to expect Hamas to renounce violence and recognize Israel’s right to exist. (Cheers, applause.)
When I think about Israel’s security, I think about five Israelis who boarded a bus in Bulgaria, who were blown up because of where they came from, robbed of the ability to live and love and raise families. That’s why every country that values justice should call Hezbollah what it truly is, a terrorist organization -- (cheers, applause) -- because the world cannot tolerate an organization that murders innocent civilians, stockpiles rockets to shoot at cities and supports the massacre of men and women and children in Syria right now. (Applause.)
The fact that Hezbollah’s ally, the Assad regime, has -- has stockpiles of chemical weapons only heightens the urgency. We will continue to cooperate closely to guard against that danger. I’ve made it clear to Bashar al-Assad and all who follow his orders: We will not tolerate the use of chemical weapons against the Syrian people or the transfer of those weapons to terrorists. The world is watching. We will hold you accountable. (Cheers, applause.)
The Syrian people have the right to be freed from the grip of a dictator who would rather kill his own people than relinquish power.
(Cheers, applause.) Assad must go so that Syria’s future can begin, because true stability in Syria depends upon establishing a government that is responsible to its people, one that protects all communities within its borders, while making peace with countries beyond them. These are the things I think about when I think about Israel’s security.
When I consider Israel’s security, I also think about a people who have a living memory of the Holocaust, faced with the prospect of a nuclear-armed Iranian government that has called for Israel’s destruction. It’s no wonder Israelis view this as an existential threat.
But this is not simply a challenge for Israel; it is a danger for the entire world, including the United States. (Cheers, applause.) A nuclear-armed Iran would raise the risk of nuclear terrorism. It would undermine the nonproliferation regime. It would spark an arms race in a volatile region. And it would embolden a government that has shown no respect for the rights of its own people or the responsibilities of nations.
And that’s why America has built a coalition to increase the cost to Iran of failing to meet their obligations. The Iranian government is now under more pressure than ever before, and that pressure is increasing. It is isolated. Its economy is in dire straits. It (sic) leadership is divided. And its position in the region and the world has only grown weaker. (Applause.)
I do believe that all of us have an interest in resolving this issue peacefully.
Strong and principled diplomacy -- (applause) -- strong and principled diplomacy is the best way to ensure that the Iranian government forsakes nuclear weapons. (Applause.) Peace is far more preferable to war, and the inevitable costs, the unintended consequences that would come with war means that we have to do everything we can to try to resolve this diplomatically. Because of the cooperation between our governments, we know that there remains time to pursue a diplomatic resolution. That’s what America will do, with clear eyes, working with a world that’s united and with the sense of urgency that’s required.
But Iran must know this time is not unlimited, and I’ve made the position of the United States of America clear. Iran must not get a nuclear weapon. This is not a danger that can be contained -- (applause) -- and as president, I’ve said all options are on the table for achieving our objectives. America will do what we must to prevent a nuclear-armed Iran. (Cheers, applause.)
For young Israelis, I know that these issues of security are rooted in an experience that’s even more fundamental than the pressing threat of the day. You live in a neighborhood where many of your neighbors have rejected the right of your nation to exist, and your grandparents had to risk their lives and all that they had to make a place for themselves in this world.
Your parents lived through war after war to ensure the survival of the Jewish state. Your children grow up knowing that people they’ve never met may hate them because of who they are, in a region that is full of turmoil and changing underneath your feet.
So that’s what I think about when Israel’s faced with these challenges -- that sense of an Israel that is surrounded by many in this region who reject it and many in the world who refuse to accept it. That’s why the security of the Jewish people in Israel is so important; it cannot be taken for granted. But make no mistake: Those who adhere to the ideology of rejecting Israel’s right to exist -- they might as well reject the earth beneath them and the sky above, because Israel’s not going anywhere. (Cheers, applause.)
And today I want to tell you, particularly the young people, so that -- so that there’s no mistake here, so long as there is a United States of America, “Ah-tem lo lah-vahd.” (Cheers, applause.) You are not alone. (Applause.)
The question is what kind of future Israel will look forward to.
Israel’s not going anywhere, but especially for the young people in this audience, the question is, what does its future hold? And that brings me to the subject of peace. (Applause.)
I know Israel has taken risks for peace. Brave leaders -- Menachem Begin, Yitzhak Rabin -- reached treaties with two of your neighbors. You made credible proposals to the Palestinians at Annapolis. You withdrew from Gaza and Lebanon and then faced terror and rockets. Across the region, you’ve extended a hand of friendship, and all too often you’ve been confronted with rejection and, in some cases, the ugly reality of anti-Semitism. So I believe that the Israeli people do want peace, and I also understand why too many Israelis, maybe an increasing number, maybe a lot of young people here today, are skeptical that it can be achieved.
But today, Israel is at a crossroads. It can be tempting to put aside the frustrations and sacrifices that come with the pursuit of peace, particularly when Iron Dome repels rockets, barriers keep out suicide bombers, there are so many other pressing issues that demand your attention. And I know that only Israelis can make the fundamental decisions about your country’s future. (Applause.) I recognize that.
I also know, by the way, that not everyone in this hall will agree with what I have to say about peace. I recognize that there are those who are not simply skeptical about peace, but question its underlying premise, have a different vision for Israel’s future. And that’s part of a democracy. That’s part of the discourse between our two countries. I recognize that. But I also believe it’s important to be open and honest, especially with your friends. (Applause.) I also believe that.
You know, politically, given the strong bipartisan support for Israel in America, the easiest thing for me to do would be to put this issue aside, just express unconditional support for whatever Israel decides to do. That would be the easiest political path. But I want you to know that I speak to you as a friend who is deeply concerned and committed to your future, and I ask you to consider three points.
First, peace is necessary. (Cheers, applause.) I believe that. I believe that peace is the only path to true security. You can be -- (applause) -- you have the opportunity to be the generation that permanently secures the Zionist dream, or you can face a growing challenge to its future. Given the demographics west of the Jordan River, the only way for Israel to endure and thrive as a Jewish and democratic state is through the realization of an independent and viable Palestine.
(Cheers, applause.) That is true. (Sustained cheers, applause.)
There are other factors involved. Given the frustration in the international community about this conflict, Israel needs to reverse an undertow of isolation. And given the march of technology, the only way to truly protect the Israeli people over the long term is through the absence of war, because no wall is high enough and no Iron Dome is strong enough or perfect enough to stop every enemy -- (applause) -- that is intent on doing so from inflicting harm. (Applause.)
And this truth is more pronounced given the changes sweeping the Arab world. I understand that with the uncertainty in the region, people in the streets, changes in leadership, the rise of nonsecular parties in politics, it’s tempting to turn inward because the situation outside of Israel seems so chaotic. But this is precisely the time to respond to the wave of revolution with a resolve and commitment for peace, because -- (applause) -- as more governments respond to popular will, the days when Israel could seek peace simply with a handful of autocratic leaders -- those days are over.
Peace will have to be made among peoples, not just governments. (Applause.) No one -- no single step can change overnight what lies in the hearts and minds of millions. No single step is going to erase years of history and propaganda. But progress with the Palestinians is a powerful way to begin, while sidelining extremists who thrive on conflict and thrive on division. It would make a difference. (Cheers, applause.)
So peace is necessary. But peace is also just. Peace is also just. There is no question that Israel has faced Palestinian factions who turn to terror, leaders who missed historic opportunities. That is all true. And that’s why security must be at the center of any agreement. (Scattered applause.) And there is no question that the only path to peace is through negotiations, which is why, despite the criticism we’ve received, the United States will oppose unilateral -- unilateral efforts to bypass negotiations through the United Nations. (Applause.) It has to be done by the parties.
But the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination, their right to justice must also be recognized. (Cheers, applause.) And put yourself in their shoes. Look at the world through their eyes.
It is not fair that a Palestinian child cannot grow up in a state of their own -- (cheers, applause) -- living their entire lives with the presence of a foreign army that controls the movements, not just of those young people but their parents, their grandparents, every single day. It’s not just when settler violence against Palestinians goes unpunished. (Applause.) It’s not right to prevent Palestinians from farming their lands or restricting a student’s ability to move around the West Bank -- (applause) -- or displace Palestinian families from their homes. Neither occupation nor expulsion is the answer. (Cheers, applause.) Just as Israelis built a state in their homeland, Palestinians have a right to be a free people in their own land. (Applause.)
But I -- I’m going off script here for a second, but before I -- before I came here, I -- I met with a -- a group of young Palestinians from the age of 15 to 22. And talking to them, they weren’t that different from my daughters. They weren’t that different from your daughters or sons.
I honestly believe that if -- if any Israeli parent sat down with those kids, they’d say, I want these kids to succeed. (Applause.) I want them to prosper. I want them to have opportunities just like my kids do. (Applause.) I believe that’s what Israeli parents would want for these kids if they had a chance to listen to them and talk to them. (Cheers, applause.) I believe that. (Cheers, applause.)
Now, only you can determine what kind of democracy you will have. But remember that as you make these decisions, you will define not simply the future of your relationship with the Palestinians; you will -- you will define the future of Israel, as well. (Applause.) As Ariel Sharon said -- I’m quoting him -- “It is impossible to have a Jewish, democratic state at the same time to control all of Eretz Israel. If we insist on fulfilling the dream in its entirety, we are liable to lose it all.” (Applause.)
Or from a different perspective, I think of what the novelist David Grossman said shortly after losing his son, as he described the necessity of peace. A peace of no choice, he said, must be approached with the same determination and creativity as one approaches a war of no choice. (Applause.)
Now, Israel cannot be expected to negotiate with anyone who’s dedicated to its destruction. (Applause.) But while I know you have had differences with the Palestinian Authority, I genuinely believe that you do have a true partner in President Abbas and Prime Minister Fayyad. (Applause.) I believe that. And they have a track record to prove it. Over the last few years, they have built institutions and maintained security on the West Bank in ways that few could have imagined just a few years ago. So many Palestinians, including young people, have rejected violence as a means of achieving their aspirations.
There is an opportunity there. There is a window, which brings me to my third point: Peace is possible. (Cheers, applause.) It is possible. I’m not saying it’s guaranteed. I can’t even say that it is more likely than not. But it is possible.
I know it doesn’t seem that way. There are always going to be reasons to avoid risk. There are costs for failure. There will always be extremists who provide an excuse to not act. I know there must be something exhausting about endless talks about talks and daily controversies and just the grinding status quo, and I’m sure there’s a temptation just to say, ach (ph), enough; let me focus on my small corner of the world and my family and my job and what I can control.
But it’s possible. Negotiations will be necessary, but there’s little secret about where they must lead: two states for two peoples -- (applause) -- two states for two peoples. (Cheers, applause.)
There will be differences about how to get there. There are going to be hard choices along the way. Arab states must adapt to a world that has changed. The days when they could condemn Israel to distract their people from a lack of opportunity or government corruption or mismanagement -- those days need to be over. Now’s the time for the Arab world to take steps towards normalizing relations with Israel. (Applause.)
Meanwhile, Palestinians must recognize that Israel will be a Jewish state and that Israelis have the right to insist upon their security. (Applause.)
Israelis must recognize that continued settlement activity is counterproductive to the cause of peace and that an independent Palestine must be viable, with real borders that have to be drawn. (Cheers, applause.) I’ve suggested principles on territory and security that I believe can be the basis for these talks.
But -- but for the moment, put aside the plans and the process.
I ask you, instead, to think about what can be done to build trust between people.
Four years ago I stood in Cairo in front of an audience of young people. Politically, religiously, they must seem a world away. But the things they want -- they’re not so different from what the young people here want. They want the ability to make their own decisions and to get an education and to get a good job, to worship God in their own way, to get married, to raise a family. The same is true of those young Palestinians that I met with this morning. The same is true for young Palestinians who yearn for a better life in Gaza.
That’s where peace begins, not just in the plans of leaders, but in the hearts of people; not just in some carefully designed process, but in the daily connections, that sense of empathy that takes place among those who live together in this land and in this sacred city of Jerusalem. (Applause.) And let me say this as a politician, I can promise you this: Political leaders will never take risks if the people do not push them to take some risks. (Cheers, applause.) You must create the change that you want to see. Ordinary people can accomplish extraordinary things. (Sustained cheers and applause.)
I know this is possible. Look to the bridges being built in business and civil society by some of you here today. Look at young people who have not yet learned a reason to mistrust or those young people who have learned to overcome a legacy of mistrust that they inherited from their parents because they simply recognized that we hold more hopes in common than fears that drive us apart.
Your voices must be louder than those who would drown them out. Your hopes must light the way forward. Look to a future in which Jews and Muslims and Christians can all live in peace and greater prosperity in this Holy Land. Believe in that. (Cheers, applause.) And most of all, look to the future that you want for your own children, a future in which a Jewish, democratic, vibrant state is protected and accepted for this time and for all time. (Applause.)
There will be many who say this is not possible. But remember this: Israel is the most powerful country in this region. Israel has the unshakable support of the most powerful country in the world. (Applause.) Israel’s not going anywhere. Israel has the wisdom to see the world as it is, but -- but this is -- this is in your nature -- Israel also the courage to see the world as it should be. You know -- (cheers, applause) -- Ben-Gurion once said in Israel, in order to be a realist, you must believe in miracles. (Laughter.) Sometimes the greatest miracle is recognizing that the world can change. That’s a lesson that the world learned from the Jewish people.
And that brings me to the final area that I’ll focus on: prosperity and Israel’s broader role in the world. I know that all the talk about security and peace can sometimes seem to dominate the headlines, but that’s not where people live.
And every day, even amidst the threats that you face, Israelis are defining themselves by the opportunities that you’re creating.
Through talent and hard work, Israelis have put this small country at the forefront of the global economy. (Applause.) Israelis understand the value of education and have produced 10 Nobel laureates. (Cheers, applause.) Israelis understand the power of invention, and your universities educate engineers and inventors. And that spirit has led to economic growth and human progress: solar power and electric cars; bandages and prosthetic limbs that save lives; stem cell research and new drugs that treat disease; cell phones and computer technology that -- (applause) -- that change the way people around the world live.
So if people want to see the future of the world economy, they should look at Tel Aviv, home to hundreds of start-ups and research centers. (Cheers, applause.) Israelis are so active on social media that every day seemed to bring a different Facebook campaign about where I should give this speech. (Laughter, applause, cheers.)
That innovation is just as important to the relationship between the United States and Israel as our security cooperation. Our first free trade agreement in the world was reached with Israel, nearly three decades ago. (Applause.) Today the trade between our two countries is at $40 billion every year. (Applause.) More importantly, that partnership is creating new products and medical treatments; it’s pushing new frontiers of science and exploration.
That’s the kind of relationship that Israel should have -- and could have -- with every country in the world. Already we see how that innovation could reshape this region. There’s a program here in Jerusalem that brings together young Israelis and Palestinians to learn vital skills in technology and business. An Israeli and Palestinian have started a venture capital fund to finance Palestinian startups. Over 100 high-tech companies have found a home on the West Bank, which speaks to the talent and entrepreneurial spirit of the Palestinian people.
You know, one of the great ironies of what’s happening in the broader region is that so much of what people are yearning for -- education, entrepreneurship, the ability to start a business without paying a bribe, the ability to connect to the global economy -- those are things that can be found here, in Israel. This should be a hub for thriving regional trade and an engine for opportunity. (Applause.) Israel’s already a center for innovation that helps power the global economy. And I believe that all of that potential for prosperity can be enhanced with greater security, enhanced with lasting peace. (Applause.)
Here, in this small strip of land that has been the center of so much of the world’s history, so much triumph and so much tragedy, Israelis have built something that few could have imagined 65 years ago. Tomorrow I will pay tribute to that history -- at the grave of Herzl, a man who had the foresight to see that the future of the Jewish people had to be reconnected to their past; at the grave of Rabin, who understood that Israel’s victories in war had to be followed by the battles for peace; at Yad Vashem, where the world is reminded of the cloud of evil that can descend on the Jewish people and all of humanity if we ever fail to be vigilant.
We bear all that history on our shoulders. We carry all that history in our hearts. Today, as we face the twilight of Israel’s founding generation, you, the young people of Israel, must now claim its future. It falls to you to write the next chapter in the great story of this great nation.
And as the president of a country that you can count on as your greatest friend -- (applause) -- I am confident that you can help us find the promise in the days that lie ahead. And as a man who’s been inspired in my own life by that timeless calling within the Jewish experience -- “tikkun olam” -- (applause) -- I am hopeful that we can draw upon what’s best in ourselves to meet the challenges that will come, to win the battles for peace in the wake of so much war and to do the work of repairing this world. (Applause.)
That’s your job. That’s my job. That’s the task of all of us. (Applause continues.)
May God bless you. May God bless Israel. May God bless the United States of America. (Cheers, applause.) “Toda raba.” Thank you. (Cheers, applause.)
Once again, I want to take this opportunity to sincerely thank the many friends who came out on Sunday morning to hear my lecture addressing both the pro and con [officiation] sides of the question regarding the role that Interfaith Marriage has played in Jewish history. I was moved by your open-mindedness as we studied together. And I was humbled by your courage to share such personal perspectives during our dialogue afterward. Thank you for your patience as I continue on this "rabbinic quest" to discern whether my position and authority as Rabbi permits me to officiate at interfaith wedding ceremonies. Most importantly: I hope you'll join us on April 21 as we continue with Session 3.
For those who were not able to be with us, the full text of my remarks from Sunday's Session 2 can be found here. The text reference sheet for Session 2 can be found here. My remarks from Session 1 in January can be found here. The text reference sheet for Session 1 can be found here.
Your questions, thoughts, and reflections are most welcome....feel free to add a comment here on the blog, drop me an email, or call the temple office so that we can schedule a meeting together.
Kindly, Rabbi Brown
This week’s Torah portion, Parshat Va’eira – the second of the Book of Exodus – may just be the most depressing piece of text in all of Jewish literature.
There is anger, resentment, frustration, and suffering….suffering…suffering. Our ancient Israelite ancestors endure the home stretch of enslavement under the gaze of the ruthless and unforgiving Pharaoh. And the Egyptians, some of them perhaps unjustly, suffer the plagues in this week’s portion of dam, tzfardaya, kinim, arov, dever, sh’chin, and barad.
I wish this wasn’t the case, but according to a new study just released by Harvard and published in the Journal of the American Medical Association: Psychiatry, this may be the perfect Torah portion to reflect on with more than 150 teens with us this Shabbat.
The study reminds us, yet again, about the tremendous pressures that are weighing down on our teens during this time in their lives in which they are particularly vulnerable. The plagues of their lives, if you will, are substantial, as they struggle to fit in, meet the high academic expectations that we’ve set for them, and find themselves….all during the same four year period. A period, by the way, in which your bodies are changing, your hormones are sending new signals, and your newfound ability to be independent is empowering you to want to experiment: perhaps with drugs or alcohol or perhaps in matters of physical intimacy.
Our teens are like the Israelites in Egypt so long ago, who are described by our tradition as geirim – strangers in the land that they lived. Our teens are geirim because we have turned them into self-conscious beings – self conscious about their sexual orientation, or their material wealth, or their skin color, or body image, or all of the above, or none of the above. Our teens are geirim because all too often the high school environments that they spend most of their time in are inhospitable to them…environments that not only on some level “allow” gun violence to happen in, but also other kinds of violence (verbal, physical, or seven sexual) that can, for example, coalesce around the horror of bullying.
The end result, which probably isn’t a newsflash to anyone in this room, is that being an American teenager today can be enormously difficult. According to the study I mentioned earlier, 12% of all American teens have found the suffering to be so difficult to deal with that they have seriously considered suicide. And 4% of all American teens have actively attempted to kill themselves. According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, suicide is the third leading cause of death for all young people between the ages of 10 and 24.
What are we supposed to do about it? And how can we make life a little bit easier for our teens?
The traditional Jewish answer has always been to turn to God. Rabbi Irving “Yitz” Greenberg, echoing the teaching of Abraham Joshua Heschel, notes that: “until Redemption, God suffers – as only an infinite consciousness can suffer – every [single] pain inflicted or agony endured by God’s creatures.” According to Greenberg, we should find relief in knowing that it’s not just that God cares when we are hurting – that should go without saying – but that, when we are hurting, God hurts too. Some of us might find comfort in knowing that God is able to be present for us, and can identify with whatever we are feeling, because God feels those feelings too.
But that approach doesn’t work for everyone – particularly if you struggle with the idea of God.
There’s also the self-help approach….the notion that we are sometimes best positioned to take care of our own mental health needs. According to this approach, sometimes all we need to do is adjust our outlook on life.
Leigh Hunt once wrote: “Whenever evil befalls us, we ought to ask ourselves, after the first suffering, how we can turn it into good. So shall we take this occasion, from one bitter root, to raise perhaps many flowers.”
That’s Hunt’s version of the proverbial dictum that we should make lemonade out of lemons. When there are times in our lives when we are struggling, we can try to turn inward and convince ourselves that it doesn’t have to be all bad. By changing our perspective, we can try to see the bright side of many difficult situations.
But for me, and for our Tradition, I think the most profound form of support for those who are suffering is not unlike the experience that we are all sharing tonight. When we are able to come together to be with each other…when we open ourselves up to being with others who are going to honor and embrace us for who we are, and what we stand for…that sense of friendship and support is deep and profound enough, in my experience, to enable us to get through the most difficult seasons of our lives. Whether it’s with a friend, parent, youth advisor, rabbi, teacher, or therapist – I can’t urge us all tonight to lean on others when times are tough.
At its best, that’s what this synagogue is all about: a space for people to come together to be with one another, as we mark the most difficult passages of our lives, and the most joyous. And that’s what NFTY is as well: a setting for our Jewish young people to gather at, with peers who are going through some of the same things they are, to learn together (as we will tomorrow), to celebrate together, and most of all…to just hang out and pass the time together….in a space that is safe and welcoming, and free of the difficult forces that plague so much of the rest of our lives.
It is worth pointing out that Rabbeinu Bachya, in 11th century Spain, made the following remarkable observation about the Exodus from Egypt. He asserted that slavery, and all of the suffering that our ancestors experienced in Egypt, ended six months before our ancestors were freed. It seems that, even though they were still enslaved, our ancestors had figured out a way to cope and survive their slavery without feeling oppressed.
That’s what I hope our young people will walk away with on this Shabbat. That you don’t have to wait until high school graduation to be relieved of some of the burdens of being a teenager. By seeking support in God, from within yourself, and most importantly: with the help of the friends and concerned adults that are with you this weekend…I hope and pray that you’ll find the inner strength to endure, and ultimately find a healthy sense of life-affirming freedom and redemption, just as our ancestors did so long ago.
I want to take this opportunity to sincerely thank the many, many friends who came out on Sunday morning to hear my lecture addressing both the pro and con sides of the question: Can/Should Jewish Law Evolve Over Time?. I was moved by your open-mindedness as we studied together. And I was humbled by your courage to share such personal perspectives during our dialogue afterward. Thank you for your patience as I continue on this "rabbinic quest" to discern whether my position and authority as Rabbi permits me to officiate at interfaith wedding ceremonies. Most importantly: I hope you'll join us on February 10 as we continue with Session 2.
For those who were not able to be with us, the full text of my remarks from Session 1 can be found here.
The text reference sheet that was handed out to attendees can be found here.
Your questions, thoughts, and reflections are most welcome....feel free to add a comment here on the blog, drop me an email, or call the temple office so that we can schedule a meeting together.
Kindly, Rabbi Brown
I hope this finds you and your family well…hopefully resting and re-connecting during this Winter Break.
I was out of the office last week. But during my time away, I found myself reflecting on the complex confluence of events that confronted me, and us, on Friday December 14.
Even after more than ten days, we are still searching for answers as to how it is possible that so many young innocents could be killed in Newtown, CT. The families of all of those who have been affected remain in our thoughts and prayers. Speaking more personally, I would share that, like a number of you, Amy and I have a precious first grader. And we have resorted to showering her with extra hugs and kisses in our home, with the hope that that will somehow be enough to protect her as we send her off to school each day.
In light of the recent tragedy, it is only natural for all of us to be concerned about the state of security at the synagogue. And so I want to take this opportunity to assure you that our staff and lay leadership, led by Executive Director Gary Katz, have been working hard since December 14 to review all of the security measures in the building. Our security staff regularly coordinates with the Scarsdale Police Department, and of course those efforts have been re-doubled. And Mazel Tots Director Jody Glassman, in consultation with Gary, has taken pro-active steps to insure that our youngest students are as safe as possible during the hours that they are with us. If you have specific security-related questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to bring them to the attention of Gary or Temple President Ellen Baken.
For those that are interested, I thought I might share just a few resources that might be of interest, in connection with the terrible events in Newtown:
· Prayers and poetry of comfort, provided by Westchester Jewish Community Services (WJCS), can be found here.
· A wide range of resources from the Union for Reform Judaism can be found here. Highlights include suggestions for how to speak to your children about death, and opportunities to make charitable donations to those affected by the Newtown tragedy.
· Sign the petition to end gun violence, sponsored by the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA) by clicking here.
· Extensive news updates, prayer/meditation texts, and comprehensive legislative resources surrounding the question of a liberal Jewish position on gun control, provided by the Reform movement’s Religious Action Center (RAC) can be found here.
Additionally, in the context of our Shabbat Evening Service this Friday December 28 at 6:15 PM (pre-oneg at 5:45 PM), I will lead us in a brief discussion about Judaism and our community’s ongoing response to mental illness. Please join us if you are in town.
Yet, December 14 was not shrouded entirely in sadness. That evening, many of us had the chance to celebrate together the occasion of my Rabbinic Installation. (You can find my words of welcome from that evening here. And my formal remarks following the Installation can be found here.) Even as we marked the tragedy that occurred earlier in the day, we also found the strength to celebrate our community’s history, vitality, and unity as we formally marked the beginning of a new chapter in SSTTE’s future. For everyone that was a part of that evening, Amy and I wanted to thank you from the bottom of our hearts. It was a night that we shall never forget. We feel so very blessed to count ourselves as members of this extraordinary synagogue community. You reminded us that even during the darkest moments of our country’s life, our synagogue can be a source of light and life, and of comfort and courage, as we seek a sense of healing from the traumas of our lives.
Damage from a rocket in Ashdod, Israel.
The news coming out of Israel over the last 36-48 hours has been distressing. After years of continuing rocket attacks by Hamas militants into Israel from the Gaza Strip, and a recent uptick in those attacks in the last few weeks, Israel and its military were left with no other choice but to respond in order to defend its citizens from these horrific acts of terror.Beyond that which has been written in the American media, I wanted to draw your attention to this FAQ sheet distributed by our Union for Reform Judaism on the situation.And, as news develops, you might turn your attention to two leading Israeli newspapers: Haaretz (whose editorial page is often left of center) or The Jerusalem Post (right of center).
In the meantime, please join me in offering prayers for the State of Israel, and for peace...that the conflict might come to an end as quickly as possible, so that the two sides might instead expend their time and efforts to establishing a just peace that might allow both Israelis and Palestinians to somehow co-exist in the world....together.
As the clock ticks down to election day, you might take a moment to check out these two profiles of President Obama and Governor Romney. Both articles speculate on the impact that their pre-adulthood travels abroad had on their character and personality.And in that spirit, everyone is invited to join us this Friday Night at 6:15 PM (Pre-Oneg at 5:45) on the Shabbat of Parshat Lech Lecha, when we'll have the chance to study and discuss together the meanings of the journeys of our own lives.
On Yom Kippur morning, two temple members shared this reading (selected by Cantor Becker) from outside of the prayerbook.
Reader #1: “Come in,” God said. “So you would like to interview me?”
Reader #2: “If you have the time,” I said. God smiled and said:
Reader #1: “My time is eternity and is enough to do everything. What questions do you have in mind to ask me?”
Reader #2: “What surprises you most about humankind?” God answered….
Reader #1 “That they get bored about being children, are in a rush to grow up, and then long to be children again. That they lose their health to make money and then lose their money to restore their health. That by thinking anxiously about the future, they forget the present, such that they live neither for the present nor the future. That they live as if they will never die, and they die as if they had never lived…”
Reader #2: God’s hands took mine and we were silent for a while, and then I asked…“As a parent, what are some of life’s lessons you want your children to learn?” God replied with a smile….
Reader #1: “To learn that they cannot make anyone love them. What they can do is to let themselves be loved. To learn that what is most valuable is not what they have in their lives, but who they have in their lives. To learn that it is not good to compare themselves to others. All will be judged individually on their own merits, not as a group on a comparison basis! To learn that a rich person is not the one who has the most, but is one who needs the least. To learn that it only takes a few seconds to open profound wounds in persons we love, and that it takes many years to heal them. To learn to forgive by practicing forgiveness. To learn that there are persons that love them dearly, but simply do not know how to express or show their feelings. To learn that money can buy everything but happiness. To learn that two people can look at the same thing and see it totally differently. To learn that a true friend is someone who knows everything about them…and likes them anyway. To learn that it is not always enough that they be forgiven by others, but that they have to forgive themselves.”
Reader #2: I sat there for awhile enjoying the moment. I thanked God for the time and for all that God has done for me and my family, and God replied, “Anytime. I’m here 24 hours a day. All you have to do is ask for me, and I’ll answer.”